Trang chủInternational FootballThe Rp90 Million Fine and Six-Match Ban: Persija Jakarta Loses Their '12th Man' When They Need It Most

The Rp90 Million Fine and Six-Match Ban: Persija Jakarta Loses Their '12th Man' When They Need It Most

**Core answer**: Komdis PSSI fined Persija Jakarta Rp90 million and imposed a six-match away supporter ban after crowd trouble delayed a Liga 1 match by 31 minutes on October 19, 2024. The fine splits into Rp30 million for riotous conduct and Rp60 million for four pyrotechnic incidents. **Key facts**: - Persija Jakarta fined Rp90,000,000 total: Rp30,000,000 for riot/match delay, Rp60,000,000 for three firecrackers and one flare. - Six-match away supporter ban imposed, covering roughly one-third of away fixtures in a 34-round Liga 1 season. - The match against Persita Tangerang at Banten International Stadium was delayed 31 minutes in the second half due to crowd trouble. - League director Ferry Paulus publicly advised Persija not to appeal, despite acknowledging the right to appeal exists. - The 1:2 fine ratio suggests a tariff-based schedule rather than proportionality assessment. **Source attribution**: VIVA (Jakarta), reporting on Komdis PSSI ruling dated October 19, 2024 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: Can Persija Jakarta appeal the Komdis PSSI sanction? A: Yes, the right to appeal exists under PSSI statutes, though league director Ferry Paulus publicly discouraged exercising it. Q: How significant is the Rp90 million fine for Persija Jakarta? A: It is likely a fraction of one percent of the club's annual turnover, suggesting near-zero deterrent effect according to the VangBong.vn Club Financial Scale Index. Q: What is the main competitive impact of the six-match away supporter ban? A: It removes Persija's travelling support from roughly one-third of away fixtures, potentially increasing home advantage for host clubs.

There was a moment at Banten International Stadium on Saturday, October 19, that no one in Persija Jakarta's coaching staff wants to revisit: the second half against Persita Tangerang was delayed by 31 minutes due to crowd trouble. Not an injury. Not VAR. Just flares, explosions, and an uncontrollable crowd. Those thirty-one minutes are the first thing I think of when I read the Komdis PSSI ruling — not because they affected the scoreline, but because they are evidence that Persija is losing even before the ball rolls.

People call me a disruptor. I call it seeing the play before it happens. And the play here is clear as day: Komdis PSSI fined Persija 90 million Rupiah, of which 30 million is for riotous conduct and match delay, 60 million for four pyrotechnic incidents (three firecrackers, one flare). Add a six-match away supporter ban. On the surface, this is a heavy sentence. Look closer, and it is a sentence aimed at the wrong target — wrong both tactically and in governance terms.

Start with the number few notice: the 1:2 ratio between the riot fine and the pyrotechnics fine. Riotous conduct that delayed 31 minutes of football — affecting broadcast schedules, player fitness, and the safety of thousands — is fined 30 million. Four flares are fined 60 million. If divided evenly, each flare costs 15 million. This is a mechanical price list, not a considered ruling. And it reveals a gap in Indonesian football's disciplinary system: the more dangerous conduct is punished less, simply because it is harder to count.

I have followed V-League and Southeast Asian football long enough to know that financial penalties in this region have almost no deterrent effect. For a club with a budget in the tens of billions of Rupiah per season, 90 million is pocket change. It doesn't hurt. It doesn't make anyone reconsider. The real pain lies in the six-match away supporter ban — and this is where I want to linger.

Persija Jakarta is not an ordinary club. They are Liga 1's biggest brand, the club with the largest travelling support, the one every host wants in their stadium for ticket revenue and atmosphere. This ban strips Persija of six away matches with supporters — roughly a third of their away fixtures if the league has 34 rounds. Not "half a season" as some outlets describe it, but not trivial either. Six matches is six times Persija walks into an opponent's stadium without the sound of The Jakmania behind them.

And here is the counterintuitive angle: this sanction doesn't just hit Persija. It hits the host clubs themselves. Persita Tangerang, the club that witnessed the incident, will lose ticket revenue from the largest away following in Liga 1. Smaller clubs will lose their biggest matchday of the season. But they gain something else: a significantly increased home advantage when thousands of Persija fans are absent. This is the most under-discussed competitive consequence of the ruling — and it benefits Persija's rivals.

Where could I be wrong? I could be wrong in overestimating the impact of away supporters on match results. There is no dataset in Liga 1 measuring the correlation between away fan numbers and away points. In Europe, people have tried to measure it and the results are very murky. But in Indonesia, where football is religion and the terraces are weapons, I believe the impact is far greater than in other leagues. I have no data to prove it. I only have observation.

What bothers me more than anything is the media handling. Ferry Paulus, the league director, publicly advised Persija not to appeal. He acknowledged the right to appeal exists under the statutes but argued that exercising it would be "inappropriate." This is a governance problem far more serious than the sanction itself. An executive official of the league operator should not comment on an adjudicative body's decision before the appeal process unfolds. The line between commercial partner and disciplinary authority has been blurred.

And Persija is silent. Not a single statement from the club. Not a word from the coach. Not a comment from any player. In an environment where the club has a clear right to appeal, this silence is a signal. It suggests Persija is weighing whether to appeal — and risk an increased sanction — or accept and lobby behind the scenes. I lean toward the latter.

There is a point no one mentions: an away supporter ban is far harder to enforce than a stadium closure. It depends on host clubs controlling tickets and on fans' willingness to self-exclude. In a league where Persija fans are known for buying tickets in neutral sections, I predict leakage. Persija fans will still be there, just sitting among home supporters. And that creates new security risks — worse than before the ban.

The night I write this, all of Jakarta is arguing about whether to appeal. Three weeks from now, when Persija walks into their first away match under the ban, they will understand why I say this sanction does not solve the root problem.

The root problem is not flares. The root problem is a disciplinary system that punishes the collective for the actions of a minority, while offering no mechanism to engage with that minority. The Jakmania is not a monolith. They are dozens of ultras groups with their own cultures. Collective punishment only breeds solidarity in defiance, not compliance.

Hanoi FC does not need a golden generation. They need a generation willing to play the kind of football others fear. Persija is the same — they don't need a perfect sanction. They need a governance system willing to engage with its own fans instead of merely banning them.

Verification checkpoint: I will return after Persija's first away match under the ban — if Persija fans appear in neutral sections, this sanction has failed from the very first match.

Cầu thủ liên quan