The Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: A Ranking Without Criteria and What It Means for Vietnamese Esports
The comment section of Kinda Funny Games detonated before readers had scrolle...
The comment section of Kinda Funny Games detonated before readers had scrolled to the end of the list. The Last of Us sat at number one in the outlet's ranking of the 100 greatest games of all time. The Last of Us Part II — the sequel a segment of players rate far higher on combat systems and level design — was placed behind the original. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice surfaced as a counterweight in the argument threads. And the most overlooked detail: no criteria table was published alongside the list.
I read it three times looking for the methodology. No weighting. No sampling method. No one accountable for the ordering. Only 100 lines of names and a wave of reaction described in phrases that cannot be measured: "many people," "some gamers," "one player said."
What stopped me was that the author raised the criteria question inside the piece and then left it unanswered. The list still stands. The argument still burns. And nobody is accountable for the order they published. In eighteen years of watching the games industry write its own history, I have seen this pattern often enough to name it: a ranking that hides its criteria operates as an argument engine, not as an evaluation tool.
Context: one list, three camps, no shared yardstick
Kinda Funny Games is a creator-driven outlet operating inside the Western games media sphere. The 100 greatest games ranking belongs to a recurring content format: low production cost, high engagement, short shelf life. The Last of Us released on 14 June 2026, developed by Naughty Dog, following that studio's Uncharted lineage. The Last of Us Part II launched on 19 June 2026.
Three camps formed within a single day. The defenders of the original argued from historical influence: the Uncharted lineage, the cinematic storytelling method, the milestone position in the industry's development. The opposition argued from systems: Part II has superior combat, enemy AI and level design, so if the rubric is gameplay quality the order should be reversed. A third group pulled Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice and other titles into the frame, demanding an entirely different yardstick.
All three camps are correct by their own measure. None of them has the standing to judge the ranking, because the ranking never disclosed what it was measuring.
One clarification matters: this is games criticism, not esports content. The source article contains no team, no tournament, no patch, and no esports organisation as its subject. The only esports contact point is the appended headline block: LCK viewership doubling after six years of franchising, GAM Esports tied to VCT Pacific 2027, LOUD returning at VCT Champions 2026, MLBB Vietnam and K/DA. Those are leads requiring independent verification, not evidence. I will return to them at the end.
Core: when criteria are hidden, controversy becomes the product
A ranking that hides its criteria generates more comments than a transparent one, and that is the entire point. If Kinda Funny Games had published a weighting of 40 percent historical influence, 30 percent systems design, 20 percent narrative and 10 percent reach, the argument would collapse into a single question: is that weighting defensible? One question. Less than a tenth of the current comment volume.
Esports contains a near-perfect replica of this mechanism. A refereeing decision published without reasoning generates more analysis than ten correct decisions with disclosed grounds. A sanction issued without a stated penalty range generates more speculation than an entire season. When everything is too stable, I start looking for the crack — and the crack usually sits exactly where the text was left blank: the methodology section.
The source article records the challenge verbatim: does this list evaluate by gameplay quality, popularity, or historical influence? That is the right question, in the right place, abandoned at precisely the moment it needed an answer.
The same fracture appears in every greatest-of-all-time argument in esports. Place a player with three world titles above someone who changed how the entire role is played, and you are not wrong — you are measuring something else. Place a domestically dominant team above a team that never won but shaped the meta of an entire region, and you are not wrong either — you are measuring a third thing. The problem only appears when the ranking declares "greatest" without stating which of those rulers it picked. Ambiguity is not a technical flaw. It is the condition that lets the argument exist at all.
The evidence for the "wave of controversy" in the source article is anecdotal. No platform, no count, no timestamp. "One player said," "some gamers believe," "many people objected." In sociological research that is a sample of zero. In sports journalism it is the raw material of a headline.
In 2026 I published an analysis of Vietnam's U23 side after the SEA Games in Malaysia built on a single dataset: fourteen goals scored across the tournament, ten of them from set pieces, or 71 percent. Contemporaneous coverage praised the team's attractive attacking play. A national-team-level coach pushed back publicly. I built a match-by-match comparison table and held the position until a technical analysis page run by the Asian confederation confirmed my figures. The article reached 250,000 reads, ten times the platform average at the time.
The lesson was not that numbers are always right. The lesson was that data does not create revolutions; it only exposes who is running on instinct. And instinct, when nobody measures it, always calls itself consensus.
The safe-versus-ambitious dichotomy is the most durable analytical asset in the source article. The original The Last of Us is a proven formula refined to the point where there is almost no room left to fail. Part II is a design gamble: a fractured narrative structure, a protagonist placed in an uncomfortable position, a player forced to endure rather than be rewarded.
In esports that dichotomy has its own vocabulary. A team that plays control, reads the map, forces opponents into wrong positions and wins on the smallest margin of error — that is the original. A team that charges into fights, bets on high variance, beautiful when it works and ruinous when it does not — that is the sequel. The LCK and the LPL have represented these two poles for years, and every time a Vietnamese team steps onto an international stage the question returns: play the probabilities, or play the moment.
Don't look at the scoreline first; look at how they move without the ball. In League of Legends, "without the ball" means the minutes without a fight: how a team controls vision, how the support rotates mid, how the jungler gives up a camp to hold tempo. That is where the original and the sequel differ most sharply, and it is also where any greatest-of-all-time ranking never looks.
Canon is not an academic matter. It moves money. When a global ranking places a cinematic, linear, emotionally driven title at the summit, it signals to studios which quality model is currently being rewarded. Conversely, when most of the dissent comes from the camp demanding systemic depth, a second signal goes out: there is still a market waiting.
The recency bias leaves a visible trace: the author builds the industry's historical arc from Pong to Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, a title released in April 2026. Using a 2026 product as the endpoint of a four-decade history is defensible editorially and distorted analytically. History did not stop there. The writer stopped there.
With The Last of Us Part II, the failure did not come from bad luck; it came from faulty design. Part II's inverted narrative structure was a deliberate decision, not an accident — and precisely because it was deliberate, it produced a group of players wounded deeply enough to keep objecting six years later. A game that induces indifference creates no argument. A game that induces outrage does.
Vietnam has no canon of its own. We have no Vietnamese-voted list of the 100 greatest games, no games criticism council, no archive of evaluations over time. What we have is competitive results, and competitive results are a very narrow yardstick that is very hard to fake.
People praise beautiful play; I look at turnover counts. On 27 June 2026, after Germany were eliminated by South Korea in Kazan, I published within 45 minutes of the final whistle with three data points: 72 percent possession, 23 shots, one on target. Those three figures said more than every tribute to a beautiful football culture. In 2026 I collected data on 90 Bundesliga matches after 16 May and found the away win rate rising from 23 to 34 percent under spectator-free conditions. In 2026 Italy won the European Championship after 34 unbeaten matches dating back to October 2026, and I argued against the crowd that this was modern possession football rather than traditional defending — a thesis proven in the opening match on 11 June 2026 with a 3-0 win over Turkey.
Those three examples share one structure: a finding, a verifiable dataset, a decisive conclusion. The 100 greatest games ranking has none of the three.

The esports headline block deserves separate tracking. LCK viewership doubling after six years of franchising is a claim verifiable through official LCK and Riot disclosures, but there is no measurement window, no baseline, and no exclusion of platform-migration effects. GAM Esports appearing as a VCT Pacific 2027 partner is a notable cross-title expansion signal — a Vietnamese organisation rooted in MOBA entering Riot's FPS circuit — but it lacks official confirmation. MLBB Vietnam is described as having global competitiveness potential, a claim that requires sustained top-four finishes at MSC or M-series level to validate. None of those headlines carries data, and none should anchor a conclusion.
Contrarian: where I could be wrong
One possibility deserves honesty: demanding criteria from a canon list may be a demand aimed at the wrong target. Canon is not a measurement, it is a ritual. People read greatest-of-all-time lists not to learn which game is best, but to argue with the person beside them about the thing they love. Publishing weightings would kill that ritual, and possibly kill the thing that keeps a gaming community talking to itself.
I also have to account for my own professional bias. Eighteen years of working with datasets has hardwired an assumption that every claim needs a method. But a large share of cultural life operates without method and still produces real value. The source article even de-escalates its own controversy with one detail: even the dissenting camp concedes the original
