Trang chủInternational FootballGoodbye, Local Strikers: John Herdman's Quiet Revolution in Indonesia
Goodbye, Local Strikers: John Herdman's Quiet Revolution in Indonesia
Core answer: HLV John Herdman thay đổi hàng công Indonesia cho ASEAN Cup 2026, loại bốn tiền đạo nội để ưu tiên cầu thủ nhập tịch châu Âu như Mitchell Baker, gây tranh cãi lớn. Key facts: Bốn tiền đạo nội gồm Hokky Caraka, Ramadhan Sananta, Septian Bagaskara, Eksel Runtukahu bị gạch tên. Đội trưởng Jay Idzes vắng mặt vì chấn thương gặp Juventus. Luke Vickery và Dion Markx sẽ ra mắt lần đầu. Nhiều cầu thủ Persib vắng do lịch ACL 2. Source: VIVA, 14/09/2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn. Related Q&A: 'ASEAN Cup 2026 diễn ra khi nào?' – Dự kiến cuối tháng 9/2026, danh sách công bố giữa tháng 9. 'Herdman sẽ đá sơ đồ nào?' – Chưa rõ, nhưng khả năng 4-3-3 với tốc độ Oratmangoen và Vickery. 'Vì sao Marc Klok bị loại?' – Nhiều khả năng do ưu tiên cầu thủ trẻ hơn, thể lực tốt hơn cho chiến thuật mới.
The training ground of the Indonesian national team in the early days of the 2026 ASEAN Cup did not echo with the familiar chants of local supporters. Instead, it carried a strange atmosphere – where the announcement of a 23-man squad created a bigger shock than any friendly match. English coach John Herdman, the former Canada boss, has dropped four local strikers: Hokky Caraka, Ramadhan Sananta, Septian Bagaskara, and Eksel Runtukahu. They were not omitted due to poor form, injury, or disciplinary issues. They were omitted for a simpler but more ruthless reason: Herdman's tactical philosophy no longer has room for them.
The silence after the squad announcement is audible. Look at what Herdman is doing: he called up Mitchell Baker, a striker playing in Europe, to compete directly with Ole Romeny – who previously was almost the sole main striker. Luke Vickery, a new name, is projected to play on the wing alongside Ragnar Oratmangoen. Dion Markx is also in line for a debut. And captain Jay Idzes, the Sassuolo defender, is missing due to an injury sustained against Juventus. Fans call this a revolution. But when I look at this squad, I see a deeper story – one of patience, pressure, and a risky promise.
Football is never a blank sheet of paper. It is always full of scratches from the past, and this list of 23 players is a very large scratch. Let me start with a small detail most news reports miss: the absence of Marc Klok. He is not a striker, but he is a veteran midfielder, naturalised from the Netherlands, and has been a mainstay. His absence alongside the four local strikers shows Herdman is not just removing a position, but removing a generation. The concept of the 'local striker' in Indonesia is slowly becoming a relic, and Herdman is writing its obituary.
The question I have asked while following Southeast Asian football for three decades is: Can a national team buy development from abroad, or is it just buying time? Football is a flow of emotions, but PSSI's naturalisation strategy has a cold logic: to immediately solve the physical and tactical deficiencies that local academies cannot yet provide. Players of Indonesian descent raised in European academies carry something local strikers do not yet possess: the ability to read the game at a European tempo. But they also carry the void of disconnection from the indigenous football culture.
In the first match I watched in Jakarta, I realized something important: Indonesian football has always had an emotional power that cannot be explained by numbers. But under Herdman, this team is being rebuilt to operate within a different system – the system of European leagues where players like Romeny and Baker have been trained. This change is not merely tactical. It is a shift in football culture.
Mitchell Baker is not a classic target man. He moves tirelessly, drops deep to receive the ball, and is capable of high pressing – something Hokky Caraka and Sananta, despite their talent, have not done consistently. Calling up Baker at this moment shows Herdman wants Ole Romeny to never feel complacent. The space Herdman creates is not about leveling, but about provoking competition.
I remember a rainy night at Lach Tray Stadium, when a local striker for Hai Phong scored a stoppage-time equalizer in the 90+4 minute – I called it a cut that split the air in two. The feeling of a goal from a local striker is the feeling of survival. Now, in Indonesia, they are betting that goals from European-based players will taste different – more expensive, but perhaps more reliable.
What interests me is that Herdman's tactics are not clearly specified. Will he play 4-3-3 with the pace of Vickery and Oratmangoen? Or a more fluid system that shifts between two formations depending on possession? The presence of Oratmangoen – who can play anywhere across the front line – suggests an intention: Herdman does not want to be boxed into a fixed formation. He wants a team that can transform, where positions constantly change to trouble opponents. But to do that, players need time. And time is exactly what is missing before a regional tournament.
Losing Jay Idzes is a much bigger blow than losing a centre-back. He is the captain, the defensive leader, and the most authoritative voice in the dressing room. His absence creates two gaps: one in the backline, one in spirit. Herdman can fill the first gap with another defender, but the second needs a new leader. Who will that be? When a team loses its captain right before a tournament, and at the same time introduces multiple debutants, chaos is inevitable without a true leader. Looking at this squad, I wonder: is Herdman banking too much on unproven factors?
Football is a game of decisions. And Herdman is making bold ones. Dropping four local strikers is a powerful signal: he does not care about reputations or history, only about what players show on the pitch. But I also see risk. If Indonesia fail at the ASEAN Cup, the narrative of 'we abandoned the local strikers' will become a weapon against him. Indonesian fans, extremely passionate and sensitive, will quickly turn if results do not meet expectations. Media pressure is at its peak right now, and Herdman seems to understand that when he says: 'I think we must promise that we will give everything we have.' That is not a promise of victory, but a promise of effort – a clever way to lower expectations.
But there is another story happening in parallel that few notice: the schedule conflict with Persib Bandung in the ACL 2. The absence of Persib players is not because they are weak, but because the continental schedule is weighing on the club. This signals a larger shift in Southeast Asian football: clubs are no longer servants of the national team; they have their own ambitions and priorities. When clubs like Persib start keeping players for continental goals, the national team will face a new structural problem.
The evolution of a national team is never a straight line. It is like the rainy seasons – sometimes the water rises, sometimes it retreats to reveal lands we did not see before. Dropping the local strikers is a bold act, but what matters is not whether it is right or wrong on an individual level, but whether Herdman can build a collective that is united enough to withstand the pressure. Only the pitch will tell, where verses are written in movement.
In Southeast Asia, where passion never runs out, Indonesia has made strides that surprised me. But I have also witnessed too many revolutions collapse over small things: a divided dressing room, a forgotten local player, an off-field incident. Herdman's use of naturalised players is not a moral issue, but a balance issue – balancing European physicality with an understanding of local football identity. If he gets it right, Indonesia could be the most formidable rival to Thailand and Vietnam. If not, the revolution will just be a failed uprising.
I see a new Indonesia, a team built from two worlds – where naturalised players and local players must learn to play together. This team can bring surprises, but it can also bring disappointment. When the ASEAN Cup kickoff arrives, there will be no more fine words, only a ball rolling on the grass. And that ball, as I often say, is the last sound of truth.
Will these experiments lead Indonesia to the Southeast Asian throne? The answer lies in Herdman's hands and the hunger of his players. Football will judge not by names, but by scores.
Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
PSS Sleman 3-0 PSM Makassar: Hiromu Tanaka's Brace and the Import Quota Question in the Super League2026-10-12
Sevilla 1-3 Barcelona: Raphinha's Hat-Trick and the Data the Scoreline Hides2026-09-21
The Zurich Collapse: Infantino, Three Rebel Confederations, and the Match Without a Ball2026-10-15
Messi Reaches 100 Goals for Inter Miami: The Campeones Cup That Masks a Single-Point Dependency2026-09-18
Adeyemi, 36.7 km/h and the Causal Fallacy Named Fufu2026-09-18
Bài đề xuất
The 114 Charges Against Man City: A Verdict Exists, But Nobody Has Read It Yet2026-09-26
Brisbane 2032's Olympic identity surfaced earlier than planned: the story lies in launch rhythm2026-10-04
The Forgotten Man of Lạch Tray: How V.League Overlooks the Feet That Keep the Rhythm2026-10-15
The Night the Data Came Back Empty: Football and What Absence Can Tell2026-09-13
Czechia vs England: The Nations League Fixture and the Information Verification Problem in Football Media2026-09-30
Bài đề xuất
A Wrong Label in the Football Feed: How a Mexican Pension Document Landed in a Sports Section2026-09-18
Chávez Jr.'s Charity Boxing Night in Puebla: A Name, a Punch, and the Facts Left Unsaid2026-09-13
Dakota Johnson and Ellen Burstyn to Play Two Versions of Marilyn Monroe in Maggie Gyllenhaal's Short Film 'Flesh Impact'2026-09-09
Mudryk and the fitness puzzle: Does De Zerbi need patience or do fans need realism?2026-09-08
Atalanta: Sarri, Pioli, Tudor and the Price of a System Change2026-10-21
Bài đề xuất
Benzema's Final Move: When the 2026 Ballon d'Or Becomes a Commercial Equation2026-09-04
AC Milan 3-2 Atalanta: A Three-Goal Lead and a Flaw That Isn't in the Defence2026-10-19
Manchester City Have Not Won at Old Trafford Since 2026: The Chance to Break the Streak Is Here2026-09-13
The 0-5 Defeat, the Thumbs-Down and the Forgotten Invoice2026-10-04
Wout Van Aert Triumphs in Stage 15 of Vuelta a España with Smart Breakaway Control Despite Shortened Route Due to Heat2026-09-07
