Persija Jakarta under Shin Tae-yong: A lesson in squad depth for Vietnamese football
**Persija Jakarta mùa giải 2026/27**: Dưới thời HLV Shin Tae-yong, đội bóng sở hữu đội hình có chiều sâu gần như mọi vị trí. Thành tích giao hữu tiền mùa: 5 thắng, 1 hòa, 2 thua. Trại huấn luyện tại Thái Lan và trận giao hữu với Brisbane Roar cho thấy tham vọng. Shin đặt tiêu chí phát triển cầu thủ lên trên kết quả, tạo cạnh tranh mở. Rủi ro: quỹ lương cao, áp lực từ người hâm mộ. Nguồn: VIVA (không rõ ngày) | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn
I still remember that day in June 2026 in Moscow, when Dmitry Volkov placed three pages of documents on the cafe table near Luzhniki. Those abnormal hematocrit and red blood cell numbers taught me a lesson: never trust the surface. More than seven years later, sitting in Da Nang, reading reports on Persija Jakarta's pre-season under Shin Tae-yong, I feel the same sensation—there is a deeper story unfolding beneath the glossy veneer of friendly matches.
Hook: A telling number
5 wins, 1 draw, 2 losses in 8 pre-season friendlies. At first glance, it is an acceptable record for a team restructuring under a new coach. But I care less about results. I care about the structure behind them. Because, as I wrote in my notebook (a notebook that does not record goals), the rawest numbers often hide the deepest signals.
Shin Tae-yong, who led Indonesia to the third round of 2026 World Cup qualifiers, is building something unusual at Persija. Not just a strong squad, but a squad with depth to the point where almost every position has at least two capable players. This is not common in Southeast Asian clubs, where the gap between starters and backups is often a chasm.
Context: The backdrop of an ambition
Place Persija in the bigger picture. The BRI Super League, Indonesia's top flight, is known for passionate fans but also financial and organizational instability. Persija, with its massive Jakmania fan base, has always been a force but often lacked consistency to truly dominate. The arrival of Shin Tae-yong—a coach who attended the 2026 World Cup with South Korea and rebuilt Indonesia—is a clear signal: the capital club is betting on a long-term project.
A two-week training camp in Thailand and an international friendly against Brisbane Roar (A-League) are not small expenses. They show serious financial commitment. In Vietnam, we often see teams prepare half-heartedly with internal matches. Persija did differently. They took the entire squad to Thailand, faced an Australian team—a costly but necessary step to test the system's true limits.
Shin's four evaluation criteria—instruction execution, intensity, attack building, and physical condition—are not vague concepts. They are measurable indicators that directly reflect the high-pressing, fast-transition philosophy he applied with the national team. This is not a coach who talks in abstractions. He is building a specific tactical language.
Core: Dismantling the system – Squad depth and open competition
What impresses me most is not the 5-1-2 record, but Shin's statement that "no player is safe" and every position must compete fairly based on training and matches. It sounds clichéd, but when coupled with a deep squad, it becomes a powerful dressing-room management tool.
Imagine: you are a starter from last season. This season, a newcomer arrives, or a young player rises, and the coach says plainly: "You have no automatic spot. Prove yourself every day." That creates positive pressure. It forces players to maintain peak form in every training session, because one poor session could cost you your place. Shin has turned internal competition into motivation, rather than letting it become a seed of division.
But squad depth is not just about numbers. It is about the quality of backups. In Southeast Asian leagues, there is often a quality first XI and a much weaker second string. If Persija truly has two players of similar caliber for each position, that is a structural advantage. When the fixture list gets congested (and Indonesia's schedule often is), the team can rotate without dropping quality. Injuries, cards, form slumps—all absorbed by a deep bench. This is what Vietnamese clubs like Hanoi FC or Viettel often lack: a genuine contingency plan.
I look at the friendly data. 8 matches, 5 wins, 1 draw, 2 losses. No xG, no PPDA, no possession stats. That is a blind spot. But from what Shin describes—improved tempo, ball distribution, inter-line coordination—I can infer that the system is functioning, though not yet perfect. The two losses are warning signals: the system still has gaps, possibly in defensive transitions or aerial defense. If these issues persist into the league season, the "development over results" narrative will be quickly tested.
Contrarian: The flip side of a seemingly perfect strategy
I am always wary of stories that sound too good. Squad depth comes with a price: the wage bill. Maintaining two quality players per position often inflates wages by 30-50% compared to a lean squad. If Persija's revenue (broadcasting, sponsorship, matchday) cannot cover this, financial pressure may force mid-season sales. That is a real risk, and I have seen no financial data from the original article to reassure.
Moreover, Shin's "development over results" philosophy is a double-edged sword. It shields him from early criticism, but if the team drops points in the first 5-6 matches, the Jakmania fans will not be patient. In Indonesia, pressure from the stands can be immense. Shin is building a media shield, but that shield only holds while the process is visibly improving. If the process stagnates, the shield shatters.
Another blind spot: the result against Brisbane Roar. This was the strongest opponent in the friendly series, yet the article does not disclose the specific outcome. This silence makes me suspicious. Perhaps it was a heavy defeat, or a match where Persija was completely outplayed. If so, it is a warning bell about competitiveness at higher levels. I will monitor this information closely.
Takeaway: A lesson for Vietnamese football
I am not writing this to praise Persija or Shin Tae-yong. I write to pose a question for ourselves: Why do Vietnamese clubs, with resources not inferior, often lack squad depth and a clear coaching philosophy? We have good coaches, talented players, but we lack a system—a system that Persija is trying to build under the hand of a man who has seen Moscow's darkness.
The 12.4 billion dong never sleeps, but it can disappear if not invested properly. Persija invested in depth, in internal competition, in a process. Results may not come immediately, but the foundation is laid. The question for Vietnamese football: When will we start laying the first bricks for such a solid foundation?
I will continue to follow Persija in the 2026/27 season. If Shin succeeds, it will be proof that depth and philosophy can overcome improvisation. If he fails, it will be a lesson in theory divorced from reality. Either way, I keep my notebook. And it does not record goals.
