VAR causes major controversy on opening day: PSM Makassar denied penalty, Greg Nwokolo speaks out

The 2026/2027 Super League opener between Persib Bandung and PSM Makassar at the Gelora Bandung Lautan Api Stadium (GBLA) on Sunday, September 6, 2026, ended with a 3-1 victory for the home side, but controversy over a VAR decision dominated the headlines. PSM had a penalty wiped out after video review, sparking outrage among players and fans. With PSM trailing 1-2, Luka Bulatovic fell in the box under a challenge from Gabriel Mutombo. The referee initially pointed to the spot, but after consulting VAR, he overturned the call. The decision left PSM furious, as a goal could have changed the course of the match. Former Indonesian national team player Greg Nwokolo, who once played for Persija Jakarta, voiced his frustration on Instagram, writing, “Baru aja mulai liga VAR udah error” (“The league has just started and VAR is already failing”). The comment quickly went viral, reflecting the disappointment within the football community. PSM head coach Darije Kalezic remained cautious. In the post-match press conference, he said: “There were moments we received, and also moments that might have been penalties. Many say it was a penalty, others say not. I need to see the footage again to understand clearly.” Kalezic avoided harsh criticism, likely to protect his team from potential sanctions. The incident is particularly sensitive as it occurred on matchday one. VAR has been a recurring topic of controversy in Indonesian football. This decision is another example of inconsistency in its application. In the match itself, PSM started brightly with a goal from Kodai Tanaka. However, Persib fought back with goals from Patricio Matricardi, Balsa Sekulic, and Uilliam Barros to secure a convincing 3-1 comeback. The denied penalty affected the game's dynamics. If PSM had converted, they could have leveled at 2-2, potentially altering the outcome. Instead, they had to accept defeat, leaving their fans with a bitter taste. Social media was flooded with reactions. Some condemned VAR, while others defended the referee. The mixed opinions highlight the lack of clarity regarding penalty-area incidents. Greg Nwokolo's criticism carries weight given his experience in football. As a former international, he understands the laws and pressure of the game. His words have amplified calls for better VAR management. Darije Kalezic's calm response shows his maturity, but it does not mean he is satisfied. He likely needs more time to analyze the situation thoroughly. Indonesian football is progressing, and VAR is a step forward. However, technology is only effective when implemented correctly. Errors in judgment or inconsistent standards can harm teams and taint matches. Already in the first round, a controversial decision has overshadowed Persib's victory. Instead of celebrating their performance, the focus is on VAR. This raises questions about the league's officiating standards. PSM must quickly move past this disappointment and focus on upcoming games. With their squad, they remain title contenders. Persib, on the other hand, will take the win but face lingering questions. Fans will long remember this moment. Regardless, it is only the beginning of a long season. Hopefully, VAR's reliability will improve, allowing Indonesian football to thrive without such contentious decisions.