Trang chủInternational FootballHerdman's Shock Move: 11 Naturalized Players Cut, Indonesia Enter FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 with a Completely New Look

Herdman's Shock Move: 11 Naturalized Players Cut, Indonesia Enter FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 with a Completely New Look

HLV John Herdman đã loại 11 cầu thủ nhập tịch khỏi danh sách 23 người của ĐT Indonesia tham dự FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 (19/9/2026). Các trụ cột hàng phòng ngự như Jay Idzes, Mees Hilgers, Sandy Walsh vắng mặt vì chấn thương. Marc Klok và Rafael Struick bị loại do quyết định chuyên môn. Key facts: - 11 cầu thủ nhập tịch bị loại khỏi danh sách chính thức - Jay Idzes chấn thương khi thi đấu cho Sassuolo tại Serie A - Indonesia nằm bảng A cùng Singapore, Malaysia, Bangladesh - Herdman trao cơ hội cho tân binh Luke Vickery và Mitchel Bakker Nguồn: VIVA | Ngày: 19/9/2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: - Q: Ai là cầu thủ nhập tịch nổi bật bị loại? A: Jay Idzes, Mees Hilgers, Sandy Walsh (chấn thương), Marc Klok, Rafael Struick (chuyên môn). - Q: Indonesia có còn mạnh khi thiếu vắng các trụ cột? A: Hàng công được trẻ hóa nhưng hàng thủ là điểm yếu lớn nhất, theo chỉ số chiều sâu đội hình của VangBong.vn. - Q: Thời gian diễn ra giải đấu? A: FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 diễn ra từ 24/9 đến 5/10/2026.

Herdman's Shock Move: 11 Naturalized Players Cut, Indonesia Enter FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 with a Completely New Look

Hook: A Turning-Point Decision

On the afternoon of September 19, 2026, at a training center in Jakarta, coach John Herdman announced the official 23-man squad of the Indonesian national team for the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 (to be held from September 24 to October 5). This event immediately sent shockwaves through Southeast Asian football: 11 naturalized or Indonesian-descent players were cut from the list. Among them were names that had become indispensable pillars over the years, such as the European-based center-back duo Jay Idzes and Mees Hilgers. Herdman's bold decision has completely altered the strength dynamics of the archipelago nation ahead of the region's most important tournament of the year. Football fans in Vietnam and across the region are now asking: Is this a calculated strategic move, or a reckless gamble that could cost Indonesia dearly?

Context: Squad Background and Expectations in Group A

The Indonesian national team is placed in Group A alongside Singapore, Malaysia, and Bangladesh. This group was considered quite favorable for Herdman's side if they had their strongest squad available. However, the injury situation and the revolutionary personnel decisions of the English tactician have created many unpredictable variables.

According to VIVA, among the 11 excluded players, there is a clear division between two groups: those who were unfit due to injury, and those who were omitted due to the coaching staff's professional decisions. Notably, the injury group is concentrated mainly on the key defensive pillars. Jay Idzes picked up an injury while playing for Sassuolo in Serie A, while Mees Hilgers is still in recovery. Sandy Walsh, the versatile full-back, was also unavailable. This means that the most crucial defensive trio for Indonesia in recent years has almost completely collapsed in a single call-up window.

Not stopping at the defense, the midfield also witnessed the departure of a veteran figure. Marc Klok, the experienced central midfielder, a regular call-up and one of the biggest spiritual leaders in the dressing room, was not named in the squad. Up front, the absence of Rafael Struick also drew significant media attention and was considered a rather surprising decision.

In this context, Herdman has actively given opportunities to fresher faces. Luke Vickery and Mitchel Bakker were particularly highlighted in the call-up list, signaling a deliberate generational transition by the coaching staff. However, this also means Indonesia will enter the tournament with a squad that has had little time to adapt and build cohesion.

Core: Deep Analysis of Tactical Imbalance and the Defensive Puzzle

Looking at the squad structure Herdman has selected, it is clear that Indonesia's biggest problem lies in the defensive spine. Losing Jay Idzes and Mees Hilgers simultaneously – two center-backs playing in Europe with good reading of the game and excellent ball-playing abilities – is a double loss that any team in Southeast Asia would struggle to compensate for. Having been a crucial part of building play from the back, their absence forces Indonesia to choose between deploying an untested center-back pairing or switching the defensive structure (e.g., from a back three to a back four, or vice versa) to shield potential weaknesses.

In a short tournament like the FIFA ASEAN Cup, where matches are played with high frequency, defensive instability will make Indonesia more vulnerable than ever. The risk of conceding goals from set pieces or quick counter-attacks is immense. The Vietnamese national team, with its well-trained domestic players and long-standing cohesion, would have plenty of opportunities to exploit the space behind Indonesia's inexperienced backline if they were to meet at this time. Even Singapore and Malaysia, though considered weaker, could spring a surprise if they employ high pressing and target the replacement center-backs.

In contrast to the defense, Indonesia's attack is undergoing a deliberate 'refresh'. The inclusion of Luke Vickery and Mitchel Bakker alongside experienced names like Ole Romeny or Ragnar Oratmangoen suggests Herdman wants to build a new, energetic, and more unpredictable attacking force. However, this also raises a question of balance. When the defense is missing its key pillars, overloading the attack with personnel and expectations could create severe imbalance. If the forwards fail to maintain scoring efficiency, Indonesia will find themselves in an extremely difficult position.

It is crucial to emphasize that giving opportunities to young players is not wrong, and in many ways, it is a necessary long-term strategy. But doing so in a short FIFA ASEAN Cup, when the defense has already suffered so much, is a highly risky proposition. This is where the courage and experience of a coach like Herdman will be tested most severely. Will he have the conviction to stick to his principles if results go south? And will the young players have the mental strength to withstand the immense pressure from fans and media?

Contrarian: The 'Loss-Gain' Paradox and Potential Positive Signals

Contrary to the concerns being amplified by the media, there is another way to view Herdman's decision. The mass exclusion of naturalized players might not be an admission of failure of the naturalization policy, but rather a sign of maturation in national team management. Previously, Indonesia was almost entirely dependent on naturalized players of European descent, which created a 'default' power structure in the dressing room. Herdman's willingness to drop big names for professional or fitness reasons sends a clear message: no one is irreplaceable.

In the long run, this is a positive signal for Indonesian football. If the national team can still perform well in a regional tournament without its key naturalized pillars, it will prove that the domestic football foundation has improved significantly. Giving young players opportunities will help them gain invaluable experience, creating a more solid next generation. The personnel changes could also help Indonesia break free from predictable patterns, making them more unpredictable to opponents.

Clearly, this is a double-edged sword. On one hand, this boldness could lead to a humiliating early exit from the group stage. On the other hand, if it succeeds, it could usher in a promising new era. We should not be too quick to judge this as a poor decision. Notice how Herdman handled the information: he clearly categorized between injury cases and non-call-up cases, showing a degree of transparency. This is contrary to how many coaches often hide the real reasons, and it builds a strong foundation of trust with the fans.

One tactical blind spot that Herdman must address immediately is the role of Mitchel Bakker. In this analysis, we have confirmed that Bakker is better known as a left-back or wing-back, not a center-forward. Listing him among the forwards in VIVA's announcement could be an indication that Herdman intends to use this player in a wide-forward role or a novel attacking role. If true, this could be a surprising tactical piece that opponents will struggle to mark.

Takeaway: A Tournament That Defines the Future

From the wet grass of Trigoria, I learned to hear the future before others see it. Herdman's bold decision is not just about a tournament lasting less than two weeks. It is the first clear signal of a transformation in Indonesian football, a shift from dependency to self-reliance. Now, the biggest question we need to ask is: Is this self-reliance coming too early, while the defense is suffering so many setbacks? A talent lies not in the beautiful move, but in how the young boy gets up after a failed one. Let us wait and see if the Garuda eagles can rise strongly or fall right at the group stage. The FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 will give us the answer, and let us observe patiently, because the true heartbeat of a team can only be felt over time.