Law 11, Law 12 and a Season Judged by the Letter of the Law
Câu trả lời cốt lõi: Từ năm 2018, IFAB loại phần cánh tay khỏi định nghĩa việt vị và lấy đáy nách làm ranh giới đo; với bóng chạm tay, Điều 12 xét cánh tay có làm cơ thể to bất thường hay không. Phần lớn tranh cãi VAR đến từ việc khán giả dùng ký ức luật cũ. Sự kiện chính: - Điều 11: cánh tay và bàn tay không tính việt vị; ranh giới trên là đáy nách. - Điều 12 sửa năm 2019, 2020 và 2021; tiêu chí trọng tâm là cánh tay làm cơ thể to bất thường. - Giao thức VAR chỉ can thiệp khi có lỗi rõ ràng và hiển nhiên. - World Cup 2018 lần đầu dùng VAR; World Cup 2022 dùng việt vị bán tự động. - A-League Men dùng VAR từ năm 2017; V.League 1 dùng VAR từ năm 2023. Nguồn: Luật bóng đá IFAB 2025/26 và ghi chép theo dõi của tác giả Phan Long | Đối chiếu: VuaBong.vn Hỏi đáp liên quan: Hỏi: Vì sao cánh tay không bị tính việt vị? Đáp: Vì cánh tay không thể ghi bàn hợp lệ, nên IFAB loại nó khỏi định nghĩa việt vị. Hỏi: Khi nào bóng chạm tay bị thổi phạt? Đáp: Khi cánh tay làm cơ thể to bất thường, hoặc bóng vào khung thành từ chính cánh tay đó. Hỏi: VAR có sửa mọi lỗi không? Đáp: Không, VAR chỉ can thiệp khi lỗi rõ ràng và hiển nhiên.
On 30 June 2026, in Kazan, I sat in front of a screen in Brisbane and wrote an analysis blog the moment the France – Argentina match ended. I insisted that Kylian Mbappe's 64th-minute goal was offside. Three hours later, the analyst Simon Talbot replied on Twitter that I was using an old version of the law, that IFAB had amended Law 11 so that the arm was no longer counted in the definition of offside. I reopened the text, read it line by line, and did not answer immediately. It took me three months to understand that the arm does not belong to the offside law.
Those three months changed the way I work. I reviewed 50 offside situations from the 2026 World Cup, built a comparison table between the wording of the law and the frame, then issued a public correction. That correction drew 40,000 reads. People remember me for that readership; I remember myself for almost turning a mistake into a habit.
Going into this regular season, sitting in front of hundreds of VAR interventions in the A-League Men and V.League 1, I still keep one reflex: before pointing a finger at anyone, I ask myself whether I have read the clause to the end. A match can be paused, but the responsibility of the person holding the whistle cannot.
Context: a system written in language
To talk about refereeing controversy in a season, you have to start with the text. The IFAB Laws of the Game are updated on an annual cycle, and every time one sentence is amended, people must relearn an entire system. Law 11 defines offside by the head, body and feet; the arms and hands of every player, including goalkeepers, are not counted. IFAB later added a specific marker: the upper boundary of the arm is level with the bottom of the armpit. The technology that draws the offside line therefore now starts from the armpit, not from the fingertip.
Law 12 deals with fouls and misconduct, including handball. Through many amendments, the central criterion became a question: does the arm make the body unnaturally bigger? In 2026, IFAB tightened this criterion after a wave of criticism. In 2026, a player who handled the ball accidentally could still be penalised if the arm was in an extended position. By 2026, IFAB removed the rule that made it an offence when a team-mate accidentally handled the ball in the build-up to a goal.
The point most spectators miss sits here: the law does not stand still, while the memory of the viewer does. An expired clause still says more than an infinite promise.
The 2026/26 regular season places two football nations before the same question. Australia's A-League Men has been familiar with VAR since 2026 and is entering a trial phase for semi-automated offside technology. Vietnam's V.League 1 introduced VAR in 2026 and is still refining its operating procedure. The same clause, two speeds of implementation, and a striking number of identical controversies.
Read the clause before you read the frame
When a handball occurs, three layers of truth overlap: the wording of the clause, the camera frame, and the feeling in the stands. The third layer is the loudest and also the least valuable. Feeling is not wrong, but feeling is not a measuring stick. Fans remember the goal; I remember the clause.
Law 12 poses three questions in a strict order. Did the arm touch the ball? In what position was the arm relative to the natural movement of the body? And did the ball go into the goal, or create a direct goal-scoring opportunity? Only when all three answers match the text does the referee have the right to blow the whistle. What is worth noting is that this order is often reversed on television: the viewer sees the ball hit the arm first, and only then goes looking for a clause to justify it. The correct procedure runs the other way.
Based on my experience following matches in the A-League Men this season, what I learned does not lie in the incident, but in the speed. A passage of play halted for too long turns a correct decision into a suspect one. When spectators wait three minutes, they are no longer waiting for an answer; they are waiting for a reason to be angry.
Law 11: the armpit boundary and the lesson of 2026
The offside section is where technology meets law. IFAB settled that the upper boundary of the arm is level with the bottom of the armpit, meaning the arm itself cannot create offside. The line-drawing technology therefore starts from the armpit. It sounds simple, but the consequences are not. A player can look offside and still be legal, because the part that is ahead is the hand. The spectator sees the arm ahead; the clause sees the armpit.
This is where I paid with three months of my life. I remember Newcastle 2026, and Clause 6.2 is still there — not as a fond memory, but as a reminder that every season can become a precedent for the next.
When semi-automated offside technology is brought into trials, the question is no longer whether the player is offside, but which point the system chooses to measure. The measurement point is a technical choice, and every technical choice carries an assumption. If the assumption is wrong, the line is still straight, still elegant, still convincing — and still wrong.
The threshold of a clear and obvious error
The VAR protocol only allows intervention in four cases: goals, penalty kicks, direct red cards, and mistaken identity of players. In each case, the standard is a clear and obvious error, or a serious missed incident. This standard is the heart of the system, and also its most misunderstood part.
A clear error does not mean a real error. A passage of play can be technically wrong but not clear enough for VAR to intervene. This is a boundary spectators often refuse to accept, because to them, if it is wrong it must be corrected. But if VAR corrected every error, the match would no longer belong to the referee on the pitch, and football would become a slower version, decided by people sitting in a closed room.
I once watched a V.League match halted for nearly five minutes over an incident in which VAR ultimately upheld the decision. The stands booed, but in my view the conclusion was right. The fault lay in letting spectators wait too long without explanation. Communication is part of the law, even when it is not written in the law.
Precedent archaeology: Perisic, Sissoko and the price of a clause
In the 2026 World Cup final, Croatia handled the ball in the penalty area and France were awarded a penalty. In the 2026 Champions League final, Moussa Sissoko handled the ball after only a few dozen seconds and Liverpool were awarded a penalty. Two moments, two different versions of the law, and one question: in what position is the arm considered extended?
Placing the two situations side by side, we see that the law does not evolve through images, but through pressure. Every time a criterion is abused, IFAB tightens it a little. But every tightening produces a new grey zone. That is the nature of a system written in language, not in geometry.
I often tell young editors: do not learn the law through controversial incidents, learn it through the amendments. Controversy is the result; the amendment is the cause. Reviewing the footage is not a lack of trust, but a way of respecting the text.
A two-way translator: Vietnam and Australia seeing each other through VAR
Sitting between the two leagues, the first thing I notice is the gap in infrastructure, not in the law. The A-League Men has the advantage of a decade of running VAR, a professional referee training system, and the resources to trial new technology. V.League 1 started later, but is moving faster than many assume. The difference is not in who has VAR, but in who has enough people to run VAR correctly.
A VAR room needs at least three people, a reserve officiating team, and a communication procedure that cannot be improvised. In Australia, VAR officials are rotated and assessed weekly. In Vietnam, the pool of fully qualified referees is still thin, so one person must carry several roles. When people are short, an error stops being the affair of one individual and becomes the affair of an entire system.
I remember a league official once telling me that VAR cannot fix an error, it only makes the error clearer. I think he was half right. VAR does not create errors, but VAR does not fix them by itself either. To fix them, someone must read the clause correctly and have the courage to uphold a decision when the frame is not clear enough.
The point I want to stress to Vietnamese readers sits here: the difference between the V.League and the A-League is not the standard of the law, but the culture of accepting correction. An Australian referee can publicly admit a mistake on a Monday and still hold the whistle on a Saturday. In many other places, a correction is seen as weakness. A mistake is a footnote; only silence is a verdict.
A regular season is not just a string of matches, but a string of pressures. Every refereeing decision in one round can shape the mentality of the next. A team stripped of a legitimate goal will walk into the following match with caution, and that caution affects how they play. Refereeing pressure does not stop at the whistle; it seeps into the dressing room.
A contrarian angle: the problem is not the referee
Most VAR controversies end with a familiar line: the referee is terrible. I believe that frames the question wrongly. The referee is the person ultimately responsible, but he does not write the law, does not design the procedure, and does not control the clock. When a decision takes four minutes to complete, the referee takes the heat, but the maker of those four minutes is an entire machine.
There is a paradox few are willing to admit: the more technology there is, the higher the expectations, and the harder errors are to forgive. Before VAR, a wrong offside call was seen as part of football. After VAR, the same offside call becomes a failure of the system. We traded an easy-to-accept injustice for a hard-to-accept one. That is a trade-off, not a pure advance.
I do not want to hear anyone say VAR kills emotion. VAR does not kill emotion; VAR merely puts emotion in its proper place. Emotion belongs to the stands, while the clause belongs to the pitch. Trouble arises when the two are mixed together, and that is when the referee is judged by something that is not in his hands.
Conclusion: the clause is still there
This regular season will bring more controversy. There will be handballs that enrage an entire stadium, machine-drawn offside lines that breed suspicion, and decisions re-litigated on social media faster than on the pitch. That is the nature of a long season, in which every round is a small trial.
What I hope for is not fewer controversies, but controversies placed in the right spot. To get there, fans need to be taught the law, not by hearing someone pronounce it, but by reading the text itself. Leagues need to publish the audio of communication between the referee and the VAR room, as a way of respecting the audience. And referees need protection when they get it right, even when getting it right means upholding a decision the majority dislikes.
I began this season with a reflex that has become a habit: open the IFAB update first, open the frame second. If you find me slow, remember that I was once fast, and that speed almost kept me wrong for three months. Fans remember the goal; I remember the clause. And the clause is still there.
